Martha's Old Mexico Restaurant

Nestled in the heart of Sebastopol, Martha's Old Mexico Restaurant serves up an authentic Mexican and Latin American dining experience that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. From the moment you step inside, the vibrant atmosphere, detailed décor, and warm hospitality make it clear that this is no ordinary eatery—it's a celebration of rich flavors and comforting traditions.

The menu is a treasure trove of Mexican classics and standout specialties that invite both adventurous foodies and comfort-food seekers alike. Imagine savoring a hearty burrito bursting with savory fillings, or starting your day with the bold, satisfying flavors of Huevos Rancheros. The Seafood Relleños burst with freshness and spice, perfectly balanced, while the Chimichanga offers a crispy, indulgent delight. Don’t miss the Chili Verde or the vibrant Taco Salad with Pork, each bite layered with textures and spices that sing authenticity.

One of Martha’s true highlights is their complimentary chips & salsa, a perfect prelude to the meal with three distinct salsas that dance between smoky, tangy, and mildly spicy. The fajita salad combines fresh greens with sizzling grilled meats, enhanced by the richness of cheese enchiladas and classic chili rellenos—each dish prepared with evident care and tradition.

The drinks menu complements the food beautifully. Martha’s signature Sangria and the potent Sangria Bola are refreshing, fruit-forward options that transport you straight to Mexico’s vibrant plazas. For a twist on a classic, the Margarita With Agave Wine and the house-special MarthaRita offer perfectly balanced mixes of sweet, tart, and spirited flavors that brighten any meal. And for those seeking non-alcoholic refreshments, the Agua De Horchata is a creamy, cinnamon-laced delight—comfort in a glass.

The dining experience at Martha’s is equally special. Customers frequently praise the back patio—a secluded, garden-like oasis filled with whimsical charm, heating lamps, and soft lighting that create an intimate, romantic atmosphere perfect for quiet dinners or family outings. Inside, eclectic fruit-themed tables and charming décor, including imaginative woodland animal motifs, bring warmth and character that make you feel part of a festive celebration.

Longtime locals like Andrea Caron attest to Martha’s consistency and quality, calling it “comfort food that helped me get through” tough times. John Andersen’s family cherishes the generous portions and the inviting, playful environment, especially for young children. Jay A highlights the tranquil natural setting of the patio coupled with fantastic food as a reason to make Martha’s a stop on any California itinerary. And T M beautifully sums it up by recommending the 300-year-old chili Colorado recipe and the exquisite fish tacos—dishes that showcase Martha’s commitment to excellence and tradition.

In short, Martha’s Old Mexico is more than a restaurant—it’s a beloved culinary landmark in Sebastopol. Whether you seek rich, bold Mexican flavors or a cozy, enchanting setting that feels like a vibrant getaway, your visit here will leave a lasting impression on your palate and your heart.

Location: 305 N Main St, Sebastopol, CA 95472, United States
Phone: +1 707-823-4458